Former CNN political analyst Chris Cillizza remarked on Friday that, despite the potential for significant economic repercussions from President Donald Trump’s tariffs, Democrats still face considerable challenges in their efforts to regain control of the Senate in 2026. Following Trump’s announcement of extensive global tariffs on Wednesday, markets experienced a decline on Thursday and Friday. During a livestream, a viewer inquired whether the anticipated economic consequences—“the tariffs backfir[ing] as severely as some economists predict”—might enhance the Democrats’ prospects in the Senate.
Cillizza, however, explained why such a shift is improbable. “They need to gain four seats, as JD Vance serves as the vice president and the president of the Senate breaks ties, so Democrats must secure a clear majority. They can have 51 seats, but there are 22 Republican seats up for election compared to 13 Democratic seats. Out of those 22, 21 are in states that Trump won last November, making it a challenging landscape,” Cillizza noted.
“The only seat in a state won by [former Vice President] Kamala Harris is in Maine, where Susan Collins is a significant target. The challenge is that they must compete in areas that are not particularly favorable to their party,” he added.
“For instance, in North Carolina, Thom Tillis is running, and I see that as a competitive race, especially since Roy Cooper, the popular former Democratic governor, is likely to enter the race. While it’s a state Trump won, it presents a genuine opportunity,” he continued. “However, it becomes more complicated from there. Remember, they need four seats. Assuming they don’t lose any of their own, Georgia will be a critical race for Democrats, as will Michigan, Minnesota, and possibly New Hampshire, but Georgia and Michigan are particularly vital contests they must retain,” the former CNN political analyst stated.
Cillizza concluded that even if Democrats manage to win in Maine and North Carolina, their chances of achieving a majority remain slim.
The next potential candidate appears to be in Ohio, where John Husted has been designated as the senator. Ohio is known to be a challenging state—perhaps. That makes three. Now, you need to identify another contender from this list,” he remarked. “I will proceed in alphabetical order: Alaska, Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Iowa, Idaho, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Montana, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, West Virginia, and Wyoming.”
“I believe Iowa might be the most promising option, possibly Florida as well. However, the electoral landscape is not favorable for them. It simply isn’t advantageous for Democrats,” Cillizza concluded. “So, while I can envision a possible route, it requires navigating through several predominantly Republican states.”
In March, Cillizza highlighted the significant challenges Democrats face in regaining control of the Senate, particularly following the announcement by Democratic Senator Jeanne Shaheen of New Hampshire that she would not run for reelection. This decision came shortly after similar announcements from Senators Gary Peters of Michigan and Tina Smith of Minnesota.
“Even if no further retirements occur among Democrats, these three departures have severely dampened the aspirations of those hoping to reclaim the Senate in 2026,” Cillizza stated at that time.
Another Senate Democrat facing potential defeat is Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer of New York. Following his agreement last month to collaborate with Republicans on a continuing resolution to fund the government through the end of the fiscal year, several members of his party have begun to call for his removal.
The most probable challenger is fellow New Yorker Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who has frequently been mentioned as a younger, more progressive alternative to represent her party in the future.
English